Forboding Angel wrote:
PicassoCT wrote:Forb, the goverment is allowed to force you and your children away from drugs...
That is a state by state issue and therefore voted in by the people. Taxation attempting to force people into doing this stuff is NOT voted on by the people, it is rammed home by congress, population be damned.
Sidenote: If a fat chick falls in the forest and no one is around to see it, do the trees laugh?
Ever considered that people could vote wrong, for example following the campaings of some millionairs voting for a bankrupt california instead of taxes?
Forb, I guess this is a anniverseray, one hundred headbangs in political threads, so for once let us discuss even long after the trolls came in. All the following conclusions are drawn on the assumption I understood you right in this thread and the 101 threads before, so if I m wrong feel free to correct it.
You stated, that everybody should be free of state regulations, to go about his own business, reducing the state to the (in?)famous nightwatchstate, basically declaring that every attempt of central government is automatically doomed because it takes intiative out of the citizens, reduces them in political terms to underage children and decends on longterm into corrupt tyranny.
Now, all the sudden the european faction of the spring board jumped to its feet in a collective ambush upon all freedome loving folks? If it only was that easy.
If I step outside, I have two kilometers too the next Roman-Ruin, a villa with bathhouse, they tried centralized government, including waters supply, street building, slavery and were driven home by freedome loving local patriots, who prefered the dark middle ages to sewers and industrialization.
If I dont travell that far, there is a chapell, dedicated to those who fell in the freedom wars against the napoleonic occupation (france occupied a hundred little kingdoms, later know as germany). What the bavarians fought against was tyranny, but one that had a lawbook in mind (code napoleon) for bavaria, which instead was later on ruled by a insane king who, spending the states moneychest building useless castles - is one of the seldome do-gooders in this history, because those castles became famous touristtraps later on, giving jobs to the decendants of the peasants who starved to built them.
Difficult to find some absolut truth in that mess? Agreed.
So how about a greyzoned truth?
State Regulations for everyone can be usefull, and if done wrong, can be very harmfull. So the populations has to have the ability (by vote) to undo a wrong regulation. In addition the population can be tricked, cheated, corrupted (oh, such a sweet poison the debt everybody shares) or just ignorant, which also goes for the people of the centralized goverment. So both sides have to have legislated ÔÇ£difficultÔÇØ ways to temporary override the will of the other side. You Forb could form a new party today, which has a refined understanding of which subjects have to be free(undecided) and which have to be law&ordered. It would work, for ten years, maybe twenty, before power would corrupt them, and some idealistic, younger Forb would have to start again.
You stated that this was no way and implied again, that mentioned above nightwatchstate would be more ideal, even better if local goverments would be run by you (every passenger on a plane today is either doctor or pilot I presume). Now, unfortunalty we tried the nightwatch in europe, several times, the results were civil wars, industries exploiting people and enviroment, crime (which is today prevented by social insurrence and public healthcare, which the us has to provide in prisons) and some other countrys (africa, india, and in parts even china) around the world who try it, right now and the results are not very promising.
Please accept for once that there is good reasoning behind some government laws and that just standing besides somebody who for example is eating himself to dead, stating ÔÇ£He is a grown adult, he know what he does, the freedom of choice annihilates every least remaining responsibility for society and humanityÔÇØ is just political escapism in my eyes.
Have a nice day, because mine was ruined by writing this wall of text.
http://www.worstpolluted.org/reports/f ... 202009.pdf