Page 1 of 1

Potential copyright infringement with TA Spring M&S

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 11:47
by Targ Collective
http://www.taspring.com/

Let's hope they don't sue. Google lists us above them, which may cost them sales.

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 11:52
by Maelstrom
Technically this is called Spring, and Spring has a mod called TA. But if there was a company called Spring that wanted to sue, we couldnt really stop them.

Re: Potential copyright infringement with TA Spring M&S

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 12:11
by Tim Blokdijk
In this case it could be a trademark dispute not copyright infringement...
Trademarks, Copyright and Patents are different things.

I don't know a lot about international law but here in the Netherlands this won't be a problem as we are operating in a different sector. (Games v/s Management Services)
And other than that Maelstorm is right to.

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 12:13
by Maelstrom
EDIT: Stupid post. Dont worry bout it.

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 13:43
by SwiftSpear
TA is a shortening for total anihilation... we may throw the term around alot and use it in the URL, but it isn't the official name of the game. You can't trademark a word against use as an abbreviation.

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 18:32
by mongus
wow how did you find that?

i could find that site iven if i wanted to.

Yes, very coincident names.

the site looks like a placeholder though.

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 20:47
by Tim Blokdijk
Anyway, I fixed the domain name thing some time ago by registering http://www.springrts.com
It redirects to http://taspring.clan-sy.com/

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 20:55
by AF
hmmm, I've been tryign to get spring.darkstars.co.uk to work in the same way google.darkstars.co.uk and http://www.darkstars.co.uk work to no avail. Fnordia has a page with just the word tmp that is shown whenever anyone directly accesses his server,

http://spring.darkstars.co.uk
http://fnord.clan-sy.com

Dammnit, I need spring.darkstars.co.uk working like spring.clan-sy so I can circumnavigate my schools filtering. I've got an A name record for spring.darkstars and a cname for taspring.darkstars, and both work the same way.......

There's also many other taspring domains such as taspring.co.uk

Overrall the engines name itself cannot be trademarked if I'm correct, it's a word, and would come udner the same rules as trademarking 'winter', or 'the' or 'hello'

Posted: 25 Nov 2005, 21:56
by Decimator
Or windows. :P

Posted: 26 Nov 2005, 00:08
by Das Bruce
I seriously doubt they're giong to be worried about it, its not like we're competition.

Posted: 26 Nov 2005, 00:11
by Strider
see that's a really awful example that proves that the american copyright/trademark system is broken on a fundamental level; however in the rest of the known world lindos was allowed to keep it's name, but changed to linspire anyway because of there american market.

Posted: 26 Nov 2005, 00:40
by Aun
Alantai Firestar wrote:hmmm, I've been tryign to get spring.darkstars.co.uk to work in the same way google.darkstars.co.uk and http://www.darkstars.co.uk work to no avail. Fnordia has a page with just the word tmp that is shown whenever anyone directly accesses his server,

http://spring.darkstars.co.uk
http://fnord.clan-sy.com

Dammnit, I need spring.darkstars.co.uk working like spring.clan-sy so I can circumnavigate my schools filtering. I've got an A name record for spring.darkstars and a cname for taspring.darkstars, and both work the same way.......
http://www.bypassit.be This is a good proxy. It has a lot of URLs as well. My school just blocked one of them today :roll:

Posted: 26 Nov 2005, 17:29
by AF
Antitrack.com is another example of that.

If I use such a proxy site, then people will look and copy and then the lower 6th will get hold of the urla dn sue ti to play games and all fo a sudden everybody si usign ti so ti gets banned. Just like meebo.com got banned so nwo I have to make do with using gmail to pass on messages in school.

With darkstars.co.uk usign the other method I have full control, if soemone else uses the link I cna change it so it doesnt get blocked and if it does get blocked I cant change it to something else anyways.

Posted: 30 Nov 2005, 13:28
by smokingwreckage
It's a different sector. (TM issue)

TAspring has been in use by the SY's for longer AFAIK. (TM issue)

Nobody with a site that cheap is gonna be suing anybody else. (random legal issue)