Page 4 of 6
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 09:52
by KDR_11k
Argh wrote:Um, did everybody not notice that most people have gotten this completely wrong? There are two "Americas", when one is speaking of continents

That's not a geography question then, that's an English question (and it has been argued that "America" can still refer to the continent and technically there's a Brazil inside the US). Are you surprised that non-native speakers don't get such subtle differences? It's still a foreign language to us, no matter how much it's used on the internet.
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 10:44
by SwiftSpear
KDR_11k wrote:Argh wrote:Um, did everybody not notice that most people have gotten this completely wrong? There are two "Americas", when one is speaking of continents

That's not a geography question then, that's an English question (and it has been argued that "America" can still refer to the continent and technically there's a Brazil inside the US). Are you surprised that non-native speakers don't get such subtle differences? It's still a foreign language to us, no matter how much it's used on the internet.
Maby it can, but it shouldn't be. It's pretty much generically incorrect to refer to the American continents as "America".
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 15:23
by LathanStanley
+ pointless thread... wheeeeeeee!

Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 15:24
by LathanStanley
SwiftSpear wrote:KDR_11k wrote:Argh wrote:Um, did everybody not notice that most people have gotten this completely wrong? There are two "Americas", when one is speaking of continents

That's not a geography question then, that's an English question (and it has been argued that "America" can still refer to the continent and technically there's a Brazil inside the US). Are you surprised that non-native speakers don't get such subtle differences? It's still a foreign language to us, no matter how much it's used on the internet.
Maby it can, but it shouldn't be. It's pretty much generically incorrect to refer to the American continents as "America".
They are North America, South America, and "The Americas"... not "America" we reserved that one for the US only.
get a clue man...
this poll sucks.

Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 15:32
by KDR_11k
LathanStanley wrote:SwiftSpear wrote:KDR_11k wrote:
That's not a geography question then, that's an English question (and it has been argued that "America" can still refer to the continent and technically there's a Brazil inside the US). Are you surprised that non-native speakers don't get such subtle differences? It's still a foreign language to us, no matter how much it's used on the internet.
Maby it can, but it shouldn't be. It's pretty much generically incorrect to refer to the American continents as "America".
They are North America, South America, and "The Americas"... not "America" we reserved that one for the US only.
get a clue man...
this poll sucks.

Fix your language please.
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 15:51
by Ishach
I thought it was pretty commonly accepted that "North America" and "South America" were two different continents.
Ive never in my whole life heard someone refer to Canada or Brazil or any other country in north or south America as simply being in "America".
edit: who the hell says "the americas". This isnt 1600
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 17:18
by hunterw
Ishach wrote:
edit: who the hell says "the americas". This isnt 1600
nobody
america without the prefix north or south means USA
also, american means someone from USA...what are people supposed to say? united states of americanites?
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 17:35
by Lindir The Green
United Statesians, obviously.
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 17:39
by smoth
hunter, for you it is texan.. for me it is coonass... simple stuff
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 18:38
by Snipawolf
coonass, lol
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 20:34
by LathanStanley
KDR_11k wrote:Fix your language please.
MY LANGUAGE WAS WRONG?...
HAR!
You ain't been to Texas have ya son?
You got some learnin to do...
what I said, was, polite.
You don't wanna hear me cussin...

Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 20:40
by Acidd_UK
This thread is totally gay.
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 21:42
by manored
hunterw wrote:Ishach wrote:
edit: who the hell says "the americas". This isnt 1600
nobody
america without the prefix north or south means USA
also, american means someone from USA...what are people supposed to say? united states of americanites?
The guys who named USA should have tough about that before naming it :)
Most people accept america as USA and americans as people from USA, but thats not really right. America was supposed to mean the continent and americans people who live in this continent. And I think that America is considered a single continent, but subdivided in smaller ones because of its shape and leght.
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 21:53
by Neddie
America is not considered a single continent.
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 22:10
by Caydr
Try "Statemen", sounds noble and dignified!
Sorry, I hope I'm not giving the impression I'm anti-American or pro-Canadian even, seriously I'm not. I'm just shocked at the state of the world in general and the public's acceptance/ignorance of the situation. It's sickening. When we discuss Americans, the foremost things are the ones I mentioned: blissful ignorance of the state of the world at large, and a totally ineffectual governing body. As another poster stated, there's just a few thousand people in power, all with totally different agendas that vary depending on what's popular or will give them political points at any given time.
Now, if we want to discuss Canada, we've got largely the same situation. There are really only 3 or 4 notable political parties, and that just means there's 3 or 4 lying conglomerates rather than 1 or 2. The only thing Canada's really ahead on is its leader's ability to shut the **** up at appropriate moments and not looking like a nuke-horny cowboy imbecile. Gotta have nukes in the first place in order to get nuke-horny.
Ah... I can't discuss this political nonsense anymore, it makes me get depressed thinking about it.
Clearly we all need to move to Sweden, they've got it right

Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 22:30
by Lindir The Green
manored wrote:America was supposed to mean the continent and americans people who live in this continent. And I think that America is considered a single continent, but subdivided in smaller ones because of its shape and leght.
America was supposed to mean whatever people think it means; that's how language works.
Posted: 30 Jul 2007, 22:37
by SwiftSpear
manored wrote:hunterw wrote:Ishach wrote:
edit: who the hell says "the americas". This isnt 1600
nobody
america without the prefix north or south means USA
also, american means someone from USA...what are people supposed to say? united states of americanites?
The guys who named USA should have tough about that before naming it :)
Most people accept america as USA and americans as people from USA, but thats not really right. America was supposed to mean the continent and americans people who live in this continent. And I think that America is considered a single continent, but subdivided in smaller ones because of its shape and leght.
That's not correct. Language evolves. The north and south American continents haven't been referred to as "America" for more than 100 years. There is no longer an American continent. America ONLY refers to the USA now.
Posted: 31 Jul 2007, 00:30
by Caydr
Caydr wrote:Clearly we all need to move to Sweden, they've got it right

Or not
http://www.snotr.com/video/41
Posted: 31 Jul 2007, 05:59
by Ishach
I'm pretty sure this thread is just a horrible attempt to try and make people look stupid by rigging the poll to be confusing.
Posted: 31 Jul 2007, 08:27
by KDR_11k
hunterw wrote:Ishach wrote:
edit: who the hell says "the americas". This isnt 1600
nobody
america without the prefix north or south means USA
also, american means someone from USA...what are people supposed to say? united states of americanites?
US Americans. That's what the media uses here.
LathanStanley wrote:KDR_11k wrote:Fix your language please.
MY LANGUAGE WAS WRONG?...
HAR!
You ain't been to Texas have ya son?
You got some learnin to do...
what I said, was, polite.
You don't wanna hear me cussin...

Your language is so broken that "America" refers to a single country. MAEK PATCH!