Page 3 of 5
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 07 Apr 2009, 16:23
by Beherith
Hmm, dunno about the no pming thing; after all in real life mafia version there is no private chat, you could try whispering tho

But also, as Bana said, the facial expressions were a dead giveaway there.
Id rather vote for no PMs allowed for villagers.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 07 Apr 2009, 17:34
by CarRepairer
I dislike honor system games where I have to rely on the integrity of others not to cheat. It is likely that most of the people around here are good and nice and want a fun game, but we can never be sure that if we set some rules like no PM that some people would violate them for an advantage and we'd never know. Better to eliminate rules like that.
Suggestion: When posting the final list of players, add a few understudies at the end, then request that each player and understudy post in the thread one more time with a "here" or something to be sure that they aren't dead. Missing players can be replaced instantly and the game can commence knowing that people who said "I'm in" a week ago aren't gone now.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 07 Apr 2009, 20:46
by SwiftSpear
CarRepairer wrote:I dislike honor system games where I have to rely on the integrity of others not to cheat. It is likely that most of the people around here are good and nice and want a fun game, but we can never be sure that if we set some rules like no PM that some people would violate them for an advantage and we'd never know. Better to eliminate rules like that.
Suggestion: When posting the final list of players, add a few understudies at the end, then request that each player and understudy post in the thread one more time with a "here" or something to be sure that they aren't dead. Missing players can be replaced instantly and the game can commence knowing that people who said "I'm in" a week ago aren't gone now.
Good idea.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 07 Apr 2009, 20:55
by Caradhras
i apply for the werewolf game
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 00:15
by Vabor
Im in. Sorry for not being there in the last game. I rage quited on the forum so I wasnt here.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 00:22
by Beherith
SwiftSpear wrote:CarRepairer wrote:I dislike honor system games where I have to rely on the integrity of others not to cheat. It is likely that most of the people around here are good and nice and want a fun game, but we can never be sure that if we set some rules like no PM that some people would violate them for an advantage and we'd never know. Better to eliminate rules like that.
Suggestion: When posting the final list of players, add a few understudies at the end, then request that each player and understudy post in the thread one more time with a "here" or something to be sure that they aren't dead. Missing players can be replaced instantly and the game can commence knowing that people who said "I'm in" a week ago aren't gone now.
Good idea.
Dunno, system is still cheatable, even more easily, provided that felix does the same group pm thing as last time.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 00:38
by SwiftSpear
Beherith wrote:SwiftSpear wrote:CarRepairer wrote:I dislike honor system games where I have to rely on the integrity of others not to cheat. It is likely that most of the people around here are good and nice and want a fun game, but we can never be sure that if we set some rules like no PM that some people would violate them for an advantage and we'd never know. Better to eliminate rules like that.
Suggestion: When posting the final list of players, add a few understudies at the end, then request that each player and understudy post in the thread one more time with a "here" or something to be sure that they aren't dead. Missing players can be replaced instantly and the game can commence knowing that people who said "I'm in" a week ago aren't gone now.
Good idea.
Dunno, system is still cheatable, even more easily, provided that felix does the same group pm thing as last time.
Understudies are decided before the game, they don't get a role if all the players show up. Understudies would be decided by order of posts in the first thread. It's basically "waiting list" players.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 00:55
by Spawn_Retard
game is going to shit, because no one can stop bawwing about rules being so narrow. Jesus, people need to stop over thinking things.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 01:00
by BaNa
Spawn_Retard wrote:game is going to shit, because no one can stop bawwing about rules being so narrow. Jesus, people need to stop over thinking things.
He's a wolf!
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 01:18
by Spawn_Retard
Last game was a band wagon thread.
Someone was offered to be hung, and everyone just jumped right on it, until the wolfs came in, and randomly the wolf votes got ignored.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 16:58
by Hoi
Becaus most of you are noobs at this game
Also the first lynch is random...
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 22:07
by SwiftSpear
That's reasonably common for the first few turns SR, The best information villagers have to go off of is voting patterns and character changes. When it's so early in the game you really have no good examples of either.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 10 Apr 2009, 18:13
by Caradhras
epic fail?
2days no post
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 10 Apr 2009, 18:17
by Jazcash
Just lock this and change everyone's name colours back to default except mine. Games like this weren't meant for the Spring forums.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 10 Apr 2009, 18:36
by Hoi
Nah, let's try one more time.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 10 Apr 2009, 18:44
by Jazcash
3rd Try coming up!
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 10 Apr 2009, 19:00
by Hoi
Stfu.
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 10 Apr 2009, 19:10
by Jazcash
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 11 Apr 2009, 00:44
by Regret
RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP RAGEBUMP
Re: 2nd Try Werewolf
Posted: 11 Apr 2009, 02:05
by SwiftSpear
Hmmm, Felix disappeared? I can run the game if he doesn't show up in the next couple days.