Posted: 27 Nov 2006, 15:55
Swift stole my words, but I'd like to add: Just because it's the fastest solution, dosn't mean it's the best one.
Open Source Realtime Strategy Game Engine
https://springrts.com/phpbb/
This is always the way it works, violence is always either the most effective possible solution but the slowest, or the fastest possible solution but the least effective. If I consider it a problem that terrorists potentially could kill me then I could go out and kill them all, no terrorists = zero chance of dying, very effective, but seriously... it's never going to actually happen. If I consider it a problem that overall on a global scale many many people are in horrible living conditions and are wrongfully killed, then I can violently force the worst offenders out of power and take control myself, but 100s of thousands of people will die in the process and the aftermath, the solution quickly attacks the source of the problem, but it does so at a cost that is equal to that which made me take the violent action the first place.Zoombie wrote:Swift stole my words, but I'd like to add: Just because it's the fastest solution, dosn't mean it's the best one.
The fact remains that they willingly joined the US Armed forces in the first place. It is a volunteer force, not a conscripted force, and by signing the dotted line they effectively agree to take on any responsibility for the organization they have become a lackey of....which just mainly hurts soldiers and their families, who may or may not be all that supportive of the war in the first place.
Tell that to the 200,000 dead Iraqis, 1 million dead Vietnamese, etc.You have no right to violence... really ever...
Unfortunately, imperialism has been "quelling" people for decades, and I can make the honest claim that my violence is left-wing reactionary, a side-effect of imperialism. They invited violent upheavel, not I. They have chosen violence as the only viable solution, not I.as soon as you militarize you invite the right of anyone who disagrees with you to violently quell you.
Your perspective is a very limited and naive (though slightly better cultured than most) of the social relations that lead to violent acts. It is hypocritical to blatantly denounce the violence unleashed upon Iraq by unleashing your own violence against the original instigators, if you take it at face value, which you have. It is not hypocritical, however, to protest an imperialistic invasion with acts of violent resistance, civil disobedience and insurrection. The way our society has been constructed and formed, this is one of the only options available to us to promote real change, particularly in the United States, where "democracy" has led to a two-party dictatorship in which two incredibly similar groups convince the people that they are drastically different, in an effort to placate their need for believing they have control, believing they have a say. They don't. You don't. I don't. Only by confronting the social conditions we are all slaved to at the most basic level, through (mass) insurrection, can we exercise any realistic form of self-determination over the beauraucratic upper class who are the only ones with any real freedom and control.This is always the way it works... etc etc etc
The news get all hot about ONE dead american but don't give much of a shit about all the other who die a useless death in much higher numbers. As if those lives had more "weight". It's about 50k to 100k people of the civil population each year which die a useless death. Apparently they're only good for statistics while those poor american soldiers who had a choice to make get all hyped up. I mean you can quit the army or not? They knew what was coming...Were angry about the Iraq war because American soldiers are being killed for what amounts to next to no good reason.
Agreed, even thoug I was doing the opposite.CAN WE STOP TALKING ABOUT THIS SHIT, IT GETS US NOWHERE...
I do this for the greater good.Fanger wrote:OH and by the way, THIS IS NOT TAU,
Oh and Spiked im pretty sure if you were joining the US Military you wouldn't be spouting this crap... in fact if the positions were switched you would be screaming at the person who suggested this.j5mello wrote:this is exactly why political discussion needs to stay the Fuck away from these boards.
And Yeah the US has fucked up. Pretty big time. We have gotten ourselves into a no win situation. We leave, the world calls us cowards, says we are abandoning the Iraqis and Iraq itself slips into civil war or anarchy. We stay our people die, maybe we make some progress and the world complains about us being imperialistic but in the end if we stay, we stay forever.
In the end (and back somewhat on point to the original topic) military personnel are caught in the crosshairs... tbh i could care less about my government. People that high up do what they deem necessary and short of counrty wide revolution not much is going change. Rather im going to support my troops. Cause in the end. They are the ones getting shot. they are the ones losing limbs and losing lives. and it sucks. All of you people who claim that americans should do this or americans should do that i have a suggestion: Get a petition together. A world wide one. get as many signatures as you can. Then send it to the UN or the President. See what it does. My bet, nothing but at least you did something rather than sitting here complaing about how everything america does is wrong or bad or XYZ. Cause in the end talk is cheap, actions cost more, but giving ones life is the ultimate price.
My guess is L-CAEKMin3mat wrote:lets play hangman! begins with
L__K
no takers?
In politics on a forum?1v0ry_k1ng wrote:people stop posting.
What I'm saying is that imperialism should be combatted by more than a bunch of whiny piss-ant anarchist kids marching down a safe street in the middle of some North American city.right, so what your saying is..
Wrong.Anyone who disagrees with the iraq war just wants our TROOPS to come back home
Unfortunately, I am unable to share with you my affiliation with any nation's military to protect my own security! Sufficed to say, you are wrong.Oh and Spiked im pretty sure if you were joining the US Military you wouldn't be spouting this crap...
I do not hate America, I hate imperialism.WE GET IT, YOU HATE AMERICA!!!
Military personelle are different because they are the armed tools of imperialism and bourgeoisie "oppression". Yes, a lot of them are poor workers or minorities who have no other choice but to be "bought off" by the military, and in a perfect world none of them would need be hurt, but unfortunately this world is far from perfect. They have signed the dotted line and picked up the weapons of imperialism, just as I have picked up the weapons of resistance, and there's no way around that.Why are military personnel any different?