Should Emmanuel be unbanned again?

[lurker]

Aggressive? He simply asked why in a large font. Smoth started in with a bit of teasing, Emmanuel responded, and you accused Emmanuel of flaming out of nowhere.

What's less aggressive than "Why did you ban me?"

[adin_panther]

WHY DID YOU BAN ME ?!
WHO DID IT ?!


That sounds fairly agressive to me. Not to mention that he is annoying in the lobby, too, posting line after line of text that no one even bothers to try and understand. Even if there is some meaning behind it all, it simply takes too long to decode before he posts the next bulk of text. Pointing it out to him does not seem to help. Some people suggested to him that he should ask some of the resident frenchies to translate to him, and we have plenty of those, most of them actually very nice guys that, i am sure, would help him if he only asked them. Of course people get annoyed at some point if he goes on and on and on ... without even trying to make it easier to understand. Handicap or not, there are ways to improve the quality of posts. I wouldn't go to a japanese forum and start making posts that only half on the people understood either, not to mention they would be loooooooooooooooooong posts, too.

[tombom]

Also, smoth didn't ban you and couldn't because he is not an admin/forum moderator.

really ? smoth dont own his "smoth forum" ?
really yu think im unbanned from smoth forum too ?
he come here for spam during inactivity in his own !

ah right sorry, didn't realise you mean his forum

[lurker]

That sounds fairly agressive to me. Not to mention that he is annoying in the lobby, too, posting line after line of text that no one even bothers to try and understand.

Don't be upset with him if you won't read his posts. I can understand them nicely while still reading at a fast pace.

[adin_panther]

Lurker seriously ... apart from ignoring everything else i said, if your only argument is that you can understand him, then it is invalid i'm afraid.

But perhaps, if you care about him so much, you could translate for him ? That would be really nice, cause then more people might be able to respond to him instead of simply adding everything he says to the quote database so everyone can laugh about it.

[lurker]

My argument is that he has done nothing wrong.

And no, I'm not going to rewrite someone else's posts for you unless you have a legitimate need for it. Example would be translating from one language to another, but it's just interesting English here.

[adin_panther]

1st, no matter if Smoth was provoking at first or not, he continues to harass him, following him into the Gundam Eyecandy thread for example. And since you asked everyone for their opinion, Smoth had a right to speak, whilst Emmanuel on the other hand just got unbanned, only to start stuff again. Check his posts, please. How is talking about someone eating shit not offensive, for example ? Of course no one could really understand who he meant, so i guess it's not an offense, huh.

2. This is NOT "Interesting" english. Hell, this is not even Yoda-English. This is like using the typo version of babelfish combined with a riddle.

[lurker]

Yes, he's bugging smoth and smoth bugged him whatever. What you're complaining about emmanuel doing happened after your oringinal posts.

Never seen definition 3, but I like it. http://www.answers.com/interesting

[adin_panther]

Yes, he's bugging smoth and smoth bugged him whatever. What you're complaining about emmanuel doing happened after your oringinal posts.

No, not whatever. Smoth wasn't the one who was banned, it was Emmanuel. After he reappeared Smoth was being quite calm actually and trying to end the discussion whilst Emmanuel was going on about it, how in the world is that NOT being offensive ? If he was so harmless, he could just let Smoth be and stay away from him, but no. Heck, i don't even like Smoth much, but he is right here whilst Emmanuel is qualifying for the next ban. Besides, we are talking about an ongoing thing that is evolving, so i apologize if my posts shift due to new facts appearing.

If i was being banned i would consider myself being somewhat of being "On Parole" when i was unbanned.


And as i said i witnessed what happened in the lobby aswell.

Edit: If you go by the definition of interesting, an accident is very interesting, too. Does that mean we want one ?

[lurker]

Smoth started the conversation and could have ended it properly with a three sentence post helping to explain his earlier ones. Instead he did not make it clear what he intended and that his end of the conversation was over, with his short hard-for-emmanuel-to-interpret posts.

And emmanuel was banned for post quality, not for doing anything, so the ban is not something that should be held against him this way.

Accident? I think you're just rambling but I'll pretend anyway that it's still part of the original topic of 'interesting english.' I'm not sure how much I want an accident, but if there is one I'll watch it and understand what's going on, to understand the interlinked structure of how the failure occured and to apply it to the future.
ANALOGY ERROR

[adin_panther]

Sure, you can always see it like that. It does not change the fact that emmanuel is going after him. And not only in this thread.

Also it does not change the fact that Smoth WAS trying to end the discussion, no matter in what style he did it. He obviously does not like him, why should he explain anything to him ? Instead he tried to avoid any flames by trying to drop out.

Oh and ... if Emmanuel was banned for post quality ... why doesn't he get banned again ? I don't see any improvement over his Posts in the past. Again ... "On Parole" ...

Edit:

Accident? I think you're just rambling but I'll pretend anyway that it's still part of the original topic of 'interesting english.' I'm not sure how much I want an accident, but if there is one I'll watch it and understand what's going on, to understand the interlinked structure of how the failure occured and to apply it to the future.
ANALOGY ERROR

Yes, it was a response to your edit about the definition of interesting. And going by that definition an accident is interesting, so is Emmanuels English. I don't see any Analogy error, since i think those two things are alike in more then one way.

[Jazcash]

Until he proves he is not a retard. Emmanuel is a retard.

[smoth]

Also, smoth didn't ban you and couldn't because he is not an admin/forum moderator.

Damnit. I was having fun watching Emmanuel rage at me for it. Ok, joking aside I also don't want him going to war with the mods. I already hate him, I just want him focused on one person and not the admins.

*edits* I tried to take the heat so Emmanuel would get over it but I was not being entirely nice to the dude. I never will be. I tried helping him out in the past as he was a royal prick about it. I do have bias against the dude and a reason to attack him. No I didn't go all out but it would be fair to say that i didn't hold back either. For me if Emmanuel doesn't like me that is fine. I don't want him coming back here and shitting up the site in some retard fit about his original ban.

I appreciate you standing up for me but I don't want your good will to be wasted on me because I was not 100% innocent last night part of my strategy was make him just focus on me. Which is entirely fine as I don't give two shits about him. For the record I have only ever banned Caydr, Argh, Jack[smug] and some random dude who hates America. Emmanuel would have been a prized ban but I never had him on my site.

[zwzsg]

Do you also want Emmanuel to rum amok in the wiki for lulz?

I mean, in the forums, at least his "contributions" are clearly marked as his, and he can't remove or edit what other people post. But on the wiki, much more serious damage can be done. Yeah, people who've been playing only BA for years don't need it, but for new people and modders it contains essential information.

[smoth]

No I do not want him on the wiki again, I presumed they meant forum only.

[zwzsg]

I hope he isn't as well, but I saw his post there and went worried. But it appears to be wiki page last changed in 2008, and his last contrib was in 2008, so hopefully he isn't. (Then .. his contribs was almost helpful).

[smoth]

it is probably all good then. He looks like he is just pointing people to the wiki.

[panzeriv2]

lurker what the hell have you done emmanuel is gonna mess up the forum with unreadable posts.

[emmanuel]

It's obvious that he is trying to provoke again. If he simply would have aasked for the reason why, there would have been less agressive ways to do it.

is the jew provoked the nazi ?

WHY DID YOU BAN ME ?!
WHO DID IT ?!


That sounds fairly agressive to me. Not to mention that he is annoying in the lobby, too, posting line after line of text that no one even bothers to try and understand. Even if there is some meaning behind it all, it simply takes too long to decode before he posts the next bulk of text. Pointing it out to him does not seem to help. Some people suggested to him that he should ask some of the resident frenchies to translate to him, and we have plenty of those, most of them actually very nice guys that, i am sure, would help him if he only asked them. Of course people get annoyed at some point if he goes on and on and on ... without even trying to make it easier to understand. Handicap or not, there are ways to improve the quality of posts. I wouldn't go to a japanese forum and start making posts that only half on the people understood either, not to mention they would be loooooooooooooooooong posts, too.

this text ²SOUND² to me insulting can we ban this one ?

Also, smoth didn't ban you and couldn't because he is not an admin/forum moderator.

really ? smoth dont own his "smoth forum" ?
really yu think im unbanned from smoth forum too ?
he come here for spam during inactivity in his own !

ah right sorry, didn't realise you mean his forum

maybe yu yu see than smoth hav an intensiv activity here ...maybee more than his own forum ?ads and lobing seems his power more than modding

Lurker seriously ... apart from ignoring everything else i said, if your only argument is that you can understand him, then it is invalid i'm afraid.

But perhaps, if you care about him so much, you could translate for him ? That would be really nice, cause then more people might be able to respond to him instead of simply adding everything he says to the quote database so everyone can laugh about it.

maybe yu want ban or kill evry people on earth that yu not able to understand ? maybe yu need a lot of sklav for translate and be in peace ?

1st, no matter if Smoth was provoking at first or not, he continues to harass him, following him into the Gundam Eyecandy thread for example. And since you asked everyone for their opinion, Smoth had a right to speak, whilst Emmanuel on the other hand just got unbanned, only to start stuff again. Check his posts, please. How is talking about someone eating shit not offensive, for example ? Of course no one could really understand who he meant, so i guess it's not an offense, huh.

2. This is NOT "Interesting" english. Hell, this is not even Yoda-English. This is like using the typo version of babelfish combined with a riddle.

if yu gramar is straight yu need more logic :
yu are ofended but not ofended bc dont understanding ?(it seems yu really understand evry vulgar parts )
smoth spam and flame and ads in evry mod forum and that dont care ...i just go in this threat 2time and write about his mod (that is never does with my !)
yu are sided against me

[emmanuel]

Oh and ... if Emmanuel was banned for post quality ... why doesn't he get banned again ? I don't see any improvement over his Posts in the past. Again ... "On Parole" ... .

adin_panther Joined: 06 Jan 2009
Most active topic: Should Emmanuel be unbanned again?
[ 10 Posts / 8.62% of user├óÔé¼Ôäós posts ]
have yu shame to show yu real name or just lobbyng for another?

lurker what the hell have you done emmanuel is gonna mess up the forum with unreadable posts.

is readable ?

Until he proves he is not a retard. Emmanuel is a retard.

for those are not making anything : play and enjoy ;

for those hav skillz like zdkfz and smoth :
i hate yu bc yu dont feed wiki and i needed to search in totala for learn
and after i feeded the wiki !
the spring wiki is feeded by some retard beginners !