Page 1 of 3

Riddle me this...

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 20:23
by Kixxe
GRAH fucking hell. A friend told me this and i can't figure it out! O.o
[20:20:32] <[WarC]Kixxe> Okay, riddle me this
[20:20:51] <[WarC]Kixxe> 3 persons walk into a hotel, and the fee is 25 Euro
[20:20:56] <[WarC]Kixxe> they pay 10 each
[20:21:23] <[LCC]IaMaCuP> k
[20:21:32] <[WarC]Kixxe> they check in, and the luggage boy (whatever you call em) comes with the change
[20:21:45] <[WarC]Kixxe> the luggage boy gets 2 in tip, and everyone gets 1 euro each
[20:22:00] <[WarC]Kixxe> now, they payed 9 euro each, correct?
[20:22:07] <[WarC]Kixxe> since they got 1 back..
[20:22:18] <[WarC]Kixxe> so... 3x9 + 2 = 29
[20:22:24] <[WarC]Kixxe> where did the last euro go?
>.<

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 20:37
by Michilus_nimbus
The equation is wrong.
look at it this way:
3x9 - 2 = 25

Although adding the 2 seems intuitive, it doesn't make any sense.

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 20:43
by Kixxe
it works in a real world example...

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 20:58
by Relative
O WAIT, IT'S A FREAKING TRICK QUESTION!!!

3x10 = 30

30 - 25 = 5

5 - 2 = 3

3/3 = 1!!! You bastard

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 21:01
by Machiosabre
3x9 is 26? every math teacher on earth has been lying to you all! call the action-news!

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 21:03
by Relative
Machiosabre wrote:3x9 is 26? every math teacher on earth has been lying to you all! call the action-news!
I feel very very stupid right now............

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 21:21
by Michilus_nimbus
Kixxe wrote:it works in a real world example...
Actually, it doesn't. Unless the mint on the pillow costs an extra euro.

there's two things making up the price:
the 25 euros and the 2euro tip. adding them gives 27, which is exactly 3x9.

The thing is, it's the wrong part of the change being used here. Adding 2 is just as absurd as adding the 25 to the sum. The total change is 5, the clerk kept 2, so it should be 5-2 in there, giving

3x9 + 3 = 30

I rest my case.

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 21:27
by jackalope
Michilus_nimbus wrote:
Kixxe wrote:it works in a real world example...
Actually, it doesn't. Unless the mint on the pillow costs an extra euro.

there's two things making up the price:
the 25 euros and the 2euro tip. adding them gives 27, which is exactly 3x9.

The thing is, it's the wrong part of the change being used here. Adding 2 is just as absurd as adding the 25 to the sum. The total change is 5, the clerk kept 2, so it should be 5-2 in there, giving

3x9 + 3 = 30

I rest my case.
you are perry mason

Posted: 12 Jan 2007, 21:50
by Kixxe
aha, after studying the answer i get it. Their visit costs 27 in total, and get keep 3 each(which = 30) since the 2 is already added in the cost! thank you! :D

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 01:07
by jcnossen
this riddle sucks

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 01:18
by LOrDo
jcnossen wrote:this riddle sucks
QFT! :evil:

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 02:13
by Dragon45
Most such math riddles tend to be based around manipulation of the original concept farther down th puzzle, so to speak.com

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 04:20
by rattle
You don't need to know any maths to solve such a stupid riddle... :P
Boy returns with the change of 5, keeps 2 and returns 1 to each.
30 - (25+2+1+1+1) = 0. Tada. Are you in junior high?

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 04:39
by Forboding Angel
LOrDo wrote:
jcnossen wrote:this riddle sucks
QFT! :evil:
x2

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 09:10
by BlackLiger
Frankly, you're a fool for posting this on a forum of le geeks, Kixxe. We've ALL heard it before, one way or another. I personally heard it in the clock sale format and worked it out in about half a second, back in High school, during maths... (my tutor had a habit of giving us oddball riddles n things)

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 11:38
by Kixxe
rattle wrote:You don't need to know any maths to solve such a stupid riddle... :P
Boy returns with the change of 5, keeps 2 and returns 1 to each.
30 - (25+2+1+1+1) = 0. Tada. Are you in junior high?
yes, and the point is that they pay is that they pay 9 each, then +2 from the tip, but that only becomes 29... if they payed 9 each, where did the last one go? (ergo so it's not "30 - (25+2+1+1+1) = 0")

but that's wrong since the 9x3 = 27 which has the 2 already included. blah blah blah.


this riddle sucks
post your own damn riddle mister smarty pants...

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 21:10
by smoth
[20:20:51] <[WarC]Kixxe> 3 persons walk into a hotel, and the fee is 25 Euro

-25

[20:20:56] <[WarC]Kixxe> they pay 10 each
[20:21:23] <[LCC]IaMaCuP> k

+30


[20:21:45] <[WarC]Kixxe> the luggage boy gets 2 in tip, and everyone gets 1 euro each

- 2

[20:22:00] <[WarC]Kixxe> now, they payed 9 euro each, correct?
[20:22:07] <[WarC]Kixxe> since they got 1 back..
[20:22:18] <[WarC]Kixxe> so... 3x9 + 2 = 29

No they paid 25 total for the room! geez.. then the bellhop took out 2 for a tip which = 27. they then received 1 each totaling roomcost+tip=27 change 3.

Kixxie, t is not that hard.. someone lock this thread it is giving me pains in my neither regions.

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 22:32
by BlackLiger
Kixxe wrote:
rattle wrote:You don't need to know any maths to solve such a stupid riddle... :P
Boy returns with the change of 5, keeps 2 and returns 1 to each.
30 - (25+2+1+1+1) = 0. Tada. Are you in junior high?
yes, and the point is that they pay is that they pay 9 each, then +2 from the tip, but that only becomes 29... if they payed 9 each, where did the last one go? (ergo so it's not "30 - (25+2+1+1+1) = 0")

but that's wrong since the 9x3 = 27 which has the 2 already included. blah blah blah.


this riddle sucks
post your own damn riddle mister smarty pants...
You challenge, I answer:

2 trains, 1 from Paris to Barcelona, the other heading the other way. First is a diesel engine and is traveling at 200mph, the other an electric at 120 mph. They collide exactly on the border between France and Spain. Serious damage and casulties. Where do they bury the survivors?

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 22:34
by Zoombie
Switzerland.

Posted: 13 Jan 2007, 22:39
by rattle
s/bury/rape
In France of course.

That was too obvious :P