Page 1 of 4

Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 01 Jan 2010, 18:08
by srapop
because as planes they move unrealistic compared to bombers and fighters,which look pretty good.





P.S. Happy New Year Eveyone!

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 01 Jan 2010, 18:53
by prankster
srapop wrote:because as planes they move unrealistic compared to bombers and fighters,which look pretty good.
good idea.

adding some combat helicopter would be nice too :D

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 02 Jan 2010, 17:42
by srapop
prankster wrote:
good idea.

adding some combat helicopter would be nice too :D
A combat helicopter would only enlarge CA┬┤s variety of Units,it has no real advantages against planes(in RL)
i see the point, having helicopters would be somehow cool :D
tank killer helicopter might be useful because it wont have to approach the tanks like an airplane(more vulnerable to AA though)
Image
That is the AH-64A Apache, it is both tank killer and attack heli, has kind of CA-interesting long range missiles.a low poly model of it would look sexy.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 02 Jan 2010, 18:02
by srapop
a gunship and a transport.
Image


Image


some models of this,i know CA is short of modelers but it would be just awesome.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 02 Jan 2010, 19:10
by MidKnight
ImageFind a role for this model (courtesy of PressureLine) that doesn't make one side overpowered and adds something to the game, and I will add it. :wink:

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 02 Jan 2010, 19:36
by maackey
Post subject: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.
I think it was just a suggestion to replace the transport/gunship models we have now with copters. IIRC the Atlas/Valkyrie needs replacing doesn't it?

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 02 Jan 2010, 19:38
by MidKnight
Ah, makes sense.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 02 Jan 2010, 20:24
by srapop
MidKnight wrote:ImageFind a role for this model (courtesy of PressureLine) that doesn't make one side overpowered and adds something to the game, and I will add it. :wink:
this model looks quite awesome.
it looks like a gunship.could go rockets instead of EMG,just to be something new :lol:
if we want to change both core and arm gunships and carriers,we need FOUR heli models! :twisted:
for first step, maybe replace banshee with the above model.(yay!) :P

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 02 Jan 2010, 22:50
by Licho
Atlas also still needs model, it could be atlas with 2 gigantic laser headlights!

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 03 Jan 2010, 05:31
by Saktoth
Gunships are down-jet VTOL aircraft. Like the Brawler or Banshee. The only example of a gunship that really doesnt fit its role is probably the rapier, since it does look like a plane (both the old and new models).

Remodelling them all to be helicopters would require significant art dev time, which we dont have much at all of.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 03 Jan 2010, 18:43
by Tribulex
In the future, helicopters are not helicopters IE they dont have big rotors. Its a terrible design for a combat vehicle.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 03 Jan 2010, 22:44
by Licho
In what future? Its more energy efficient to use lift from rotor.
Only problem is radar reflectivity and noise.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 04 Jan 2010, 00:02
by Tribulex
and the fact that it get's hit and your screwed. If you make a heli you better give it like 1 hp if u want it to be realistic.


Energy efficient? Thats 100% false. There are incredible amounts of turbulence generated by the rotor that actually work AGAINST lift.

Basically its a terrible design.

However i guess that would fit in to ca pretty well, and i would actually laugh out loud if i got to fps a heli in ca, so sure go ahead. Just telling you guys...

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 04 Jan 2010, 04:24
by Licho
If rotor was less efficient than jet engines all helis would already use that. But there are just few crafts that use direct hovering and they sux, cant even hover properly fully loaded (harrier).
Helicopters can also use auto rotation to land gently if engine malfunctions. Direct hovering craft would fall down like rock.

Real world is not like CA, if helicopter gets hit by anything serious into any spot its dead. Does not matter if its rotor or jet engine.

Weapons beat armor.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 04 Jan 2010, 06:44
by MidKnight
Even if Tribulex were right, transports are made of paper anyway. :P

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 05 Jan 2010, 07:32
by Noruas
Licho wrote:In what future? Its more energy efficient to use lift from rotor.
Only problem is radar reflectivity and noise.
Well then you have no idea how top secret helicopters work today... Its been already solved but i decided not to say it.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 05 Jan 2010, 17:29
by srapop
we should focus on the topic.
for the guys complaining about the realism,that is why this thread is here.
since some gunships can be VTOL,we should just change the rapier.
if anyone wants to,(and has the time) he can still remodel the other ones,like valkyrie (BIG HEADLIGHTS!)and the simple gunships.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 05 Jan 2010, 18:57
by Licho
Or someone could retexture this heli and it could be rapier. I dont see reason why not.

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 05 Jan 2010, 19:28
by Pxtl
If you compare the performance of the A-10 and the new unmanned drones vs. the Army helicopters, you can make a good argument that combat helicopters are a solution looking for a problem - only invented for bureaucratic reasons (the US Army is not allowed to operate fixed-wing aircraft).

Re: Air Transports and Gunships should be Helicopters.

Posted: 05 Jan 2010, 20:14
by Neddie
Licho wrote:Or someone could retexture this heli and it could be rapier. I dont see reason why not.
Well, for 1faction or for CA? Because the model is distinctly unlike Logos.