Page 1 of 2

Should BA use graphics from other mods?

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 10:32
by RavingManiac
In the light of a recent discussion in the BA forums, I have decided to hold a poll to see what the community thinks of BA's graphics.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 10:37
by SwiftSpear
This is why I don't like polls.

You take an issue you have no say in, and is not origional, and pose it in such a way that it seems like democracy matters.

There are various reasons why BA currently doesn't use as advanced special effects as other mods, and most of those reasons won't be changed in the lifetime of this poll.

BA would use better effects if it were as easy as a push button solution, rest assured it's not. Not remotely.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 11:10
by Felix the Cat
This poll is missing the ham sandwich option.

(for the OMG WTF IS HE TALKIN BOUT HE R OFFTOPICZ TROLL LOCK crowd: in other words, I agree with Swifty)

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 12:58
by 1v0ry_k1ng
what mod did you intend to steal from?

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 14:49
by REVENGE
1v0ry_k1ng wrote:what man did you intend to steal from?
smoth

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 14:52
by Pressure Line
ibtl. want pretty graphics? play CA, or TiA, or The Fifth Millenium. its been stated 1000 times, BA is about the balance, not what the lazurz look like.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 15:51
by Fanger
stupid people who think we cant have our cake and eat it too..

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 16:54
by Noruas
I am sorry, but whether its stealing or asking people in other mods for permission, this is a fucking insult to all those other people who make their mod shinier on purpose to get people to try their mod for a change. Of course everyone will say yes, i already donated* a few effects to BA, I even told them i do not like this*, and they should make their own effects like everyone else. I am deeply offended by this poll.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 18:24
by Zpock
Unless I'm mistaken, since someone made an EA ("Epic Annihilation") we are now on the letter F. This is a good opportunity for someone (like you) to make a new mod, FA, for Flashy Annihilation. What you do is steal effects/models/etc from all the other mods, and use EXACTLY the balance from BA. Then call it FA 6.12 or something, so you have a high version number, its very important. Would be interesting to see if you would get players.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 18:27
by cong06
Zpock wrote:Unless I'm mistaken, since someone made an EA ("Epic Annihilation") we are now on the letter F. This is a good opportunity for someone (like you) to make a new mod, FA, for Flashy Annihilation.
because what we all need are more *A mods.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 18:35
by LordMatt
Noruas wrote:I am sorry, but whether its stealing or asking people in other mods for permission, this is a fucking insult to all those other people who make their mod shinier on purpose to get people to try their mod for a change. Of course everyone will say yes, i already donated* a few effects to BA, I even told them i do not like this*, and they should make their own effects like everyone else. I am deeply offended by this poll.
Oo so BA is not allowed to improve because it might make people less likely to play other mods? I don't think anyone involved with BA has ever advocated stealing content from anyone, and if someone chooses to let BA use some of their content, that's their choice not yours.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 19:02
by 1v0ry_k1ng
LordMatt wrote:I don't think anyone involved with BA has ever advocated stealing content from anyone
If I had time on my hands I would traul back through the BA thread(s) and find you a truckload of examples of "LOZL LETZ STEALS" but sadly Im not tired

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 19:04
by Peet
Zpock wrote:Unless I'm mistaken, since someone made an EA ("Epic Annihilation") we are now on the letter F. This is a good opportunity for someone (like you) to make a new mod, FA, for Flashy Annihilation. What you do is steal effects/models/etc from all the other mods, and use EXACTLY the balance from BA. Then call it FA 6.12 or something, so you have a high version number, its very important. Would be interesting to see if you would get players.
If it's called flashy annihilation, I demand that flashes recieve a major buff.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 19:57
by CautionToTheWind
Now if only we had some sort of asshole that would steal from all and get it done!

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 20:32
by tombom
1v0ry_k1ng wrote:If I had time on my hands I would traul back through the BA thread(s) and find you a truckload of examples of "LOZL LETZ STEALS" but sadly Im not tired
I doubt it was from Day or NOiZE, who are really the only people who matter.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 20:36
by smoth
if ba wanted to it would have done so by now. CA uses PD for it's effects and gundam has a mild CC attribution for it's effects. If ba people wanted their mod to not look like crap they would have done it already. However, flashy aka entertaining explosions are not a priority to them.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 20:39
by LordMatt
1v0ry_k1ng wrote:
LordMatt wrote:I don't think anyone involved with BA has ever advocated stealing content from anyone
If I had time on my hands I would traul back through the BA thread(s) and find you a truckload of examples of "LOZL LETZ STEALS" but sadly Im not tired
That's not an argument, that's just BS. Either provide some examples or they don't exist. Also +1 to tombom.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 20:44
by clericvash
And why is this topic still open, come on mods, its pointless.

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 21:19
by Pressure Line
Fanger wrote:stupid people who think we cant have our cake and eat it too..
its not that at all fang, its just a simple "I have better things to do than run around attaching cegs and redoing the weapons for 300 units"

Posted: 21 Oct 2007, 21:36
by smoth
Pressure Line wrote:
Fanger wrote:stupid people who think we cant have our cake and eat it too..
its not that at all fang, its just a simple "I have better things to do than run around attaching cegs and redoing the weapons for 300 units"
like change a handfull of stats and then sit around.