Page 4 of 6

Posted: 19 Mar 2007, 05:25
by Neddie
Issac is practicing the ancient art of sarcasm, but for him, I'm sure play is more important than asthetics.

Posted: 19 Mar 2007, 05:37
by Ishach
it might seem like it, but im serious i dont care what a map looks like in the slightest

Posted: 19 Mar 2007, 07:43
by Argh
Well, I've just built us a decent test map to play with. Not some fricking gigantic over-prettified lagfest, but a tight 8X8 that should perform well even on not-so-awesome hardware.

And Forb, what part of Tobi's independent verification of my results did you miss? I could add a lot more points, but oh noes, that'd be flaming :roll: Heaven forfend that somebody gave your attitude back to you ;)

Posted: 19 Mar 2007, 07:45
by smoth
fire the 8X8 to me I will post framerates. any settings that you want me to test?

Posted: 19 Mar 2007, 07:47
by Argh
Go here.

And no, keep your settings on whatever you normally use. Since you get terrible FPS with other SM3s, you're the baseline.

Posted: 19 Mar 2007, 20:37
by LordMatt
I don't think we need to make posts like those two. You can PM your thoughts to Argh and FA if necessary.

Posted: 19 Mar 2007, 22:24
by BoredJoe
I've just tested FA's SM3 map and SMF map of the same thing.

With no AA, the SM3 map performs a lot better than SMF. In Tab view SM3 gets ~ 45-50 more fps, at close up view ~35-40 more fps, and in middle range views ~10-20 more fps. The only time SMF gets better fps is when it isn't having to render much (e.g. zoomed out in a corner, or in a fps view). It gets 200-300 fps, where as SM3 stays pretty stable at around 90.

With 8x AA SMF gets ~10-20 more fps consistently in pretty much all views.

Posted: 22 Mar 2007, 22:35
by zwzsg
Making everyone waits 3/4 hr is so much fun!

Image

Posted: 22 Mar 2007, 23:53
by Forboding Angel
Want a tissue?

:roll:

I don't make maps for other people. I make them first and foremost primarily for me. Cry and whine all you like, but I don't care. I never asked you to play on any of my maps. They are simply there in case you decide that you would like do play on them. Therefore, don't come whining to me if you don't like your decision.

I design my maps to show off the best visual quality (and hopefully in most cases gameplay) that spring has to offer. If you don't like it, mars and smalldivide come packaged with spring.

In the end, I'm not making you do a damn thing. You are doing it because you made a choice. I am not to be blamed for your choices. There are plenty of games available to be played on altored.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 01:59
by smoth
zwzsg, it does not take me 3/4 of an hour.. maybe 10 minutes for me. Is it the server that is causing slow download for you or is it your connection?

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 02:30
by Felix the Cat
Forboding Angel wrote:Want a tissue?

:roll:

I don't make maps for other people. I make them first and foremost primarily for me. Cry and whine all you like, but I don't care. I never asked you to play on any of my maps. They are simply there in case you decide that you would like do play on them. Therefore, don't come whining to me if you don't like your decision.

I design my maps to show off the best visual quality (and hopefully in most cases gameplay) that spring has to offer. If you don't like it, mars and smalldivide come packaged with spring.

In the end, I'm not making you do a damn thing. You are doing it because you made a choice. I am not to be blamed for your choices. There are plenty of games available to be played on altored.
That's very Randian of you, Forb.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 03:27
by Neddie
Hey, nobody is perfect.

Remember, you can't be an Objectivist unless you ascribe to the entire philosophy by Ayn's words, and while you're similar to an American Libertarian, you're supposed to hate them.

Yeah, I'm not fond of Rand.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 04:03
by Nemo
But everybody loves 50 page monologues and wooden characters! What's more, everyone loves books that make their point by page 200, but continue to page 1080!


Reading Atlas Shrugged ranks top five on my list of "things I wish I'd never done, because I hated myself for doing them"

Uh, right. In other news.

I suppose the best thing to do with giant maps like that is consider them akin to Picasso's work and look at them from a asthetic standpoint, rather than a practical map for tournament play or whatever.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 04:04
by smoth
what was it that you described me as neddie?

BTW: Ayn's Romantic Manifesto is now on my "to read list" after I finish the foundation series.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 04:05
by smoth
Nemo wrote: I suppose the best thing to do with giant maps like that is consider them akin to Picasso's work and look at them from a asthetic standpoint, rather than a practical map for tournament play or whatever.
Ah, but see nemo, gundam plays well on maps that are 20X20 or larger.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 04:36
by Nemo
Giant filesize (ie, Picasso's multiple 80+mb maps don't stand a chance of getting much playtime), rather than map size. I'm just saying that maps with a large filesize (like almost all of Picassos, some of Forbs) are impractical for most groups of players, because there will always be a few people in a battleroom who don't have a super fast connection.

I totally understand that various mods work best on maps of a certain size.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 04:47
by Forboding Angel
zwzsg wrote:Making everyone waits 3/4 hr is so much fun!
Some of oyu may not have understood what I said. So I''ll as it in a few sentences this time...

He says that I personally am making everyone in his game wait for 3/4ths of an hour to play. That is complete bullshit. HE is making everyone wait 3/4ths of an hour because he does not have the map that they want to play on yet. I had nothing to do with it.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 10:12
by aGorm
I'm actully with forbding on this one... its his map he can make it as big as he likes.

(besides then maybe more people would download my maps with there resonable file sizes... :P )

aGorm

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 17:13
by smoth
in all honesty, I just download every map I can get. I then delete ones that are not worth keeping.. no I will not say names.

Posted: 23 Mar 2007, 17:35
by Neddie
smoth wrote:what was it that you described me as neddie?

BTW: Ayn's Romantic Manifesto is now on my "to read list" after I finish the foundation series.
I described you as what? I'm missing the line - but I assume it has something to do with dear old deluded Rand.