Page 3 of 4

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 08:20
by manolo_
luckywaldo7 wrote:This kind of thing should probably be organized by someone who is not a member of a participating clan.

Also there are plenty of SINners, but not many of them both browse the forums regularly and consider themselves to be XTA players.
take me, im a member of cow, BUT didnt played since 3 months. so pm me the results and i make the table/board

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 13:35
by Tim-the-maniac
Yeah someone else updating it would be fine, I only started it as noone else had.

But the crying in this thread is more due to babbles and shift losing, if people would actually read through it properly they would see that all I said was against smurfing and nothing else..

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 15:06
by Spawn_Retard
im not crying, you all knew who he was.


dont troll bait me ray.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 16:15
by manolo_
Tsssch both of you, i think xta has greater problems than that gameboard and BTW 2 i repeat TWO games since the 6th of april

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 16:24
by Teutooni
Less drama, more high quality games pls.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 19:42
by Neddie
Ray requested I restore his post, since Noruas defaced it. I understand that some people don't like this because of other concerns with the guidelines for the clan league, but when a user makes a legitimate request I try to fulfill it.
This kind of thing should probably be organized by someone who is not a member of a participating clan.
If desired, I can do this, but I'll require reports and replays either in thread or in private message to confirm the results of matches, since I am unable to play myself.
Teutooni wrote:Less drama, more high quality games
I agree.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 21:37
by Teutooni
luckywaldo7 wrote:This kind of thing should probably be organized by someone who is not a member of a participating clan.
Tim-the-maniac wrote:Yeah someone else updating it would be fine, I only started it as noone else had.
Btw I could probably keep the score, as I'm not in any clan participating in this league, and I've been fairly active... Just ask.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 21:44
by Gota
What league?what games?who?where?when?
Where is the scoreboard?
What counts a clan match in the league?why dont 1v1s count?
What are the official rules?can i make air lab and combomb?can I dgun a commander?can i laser a commander to death and win?

Seems like a drama thread instead of what it should have been.
If there is not gonna be at least a simple visual scoreboard this will not last long I am 95% sure.

---big question mark---

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 22:06
by Neddie
There is a simple score board, look at the first post.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 22:53
by Tim-the-maniac
Gota wrote:What league?what games?who?where?when?
Where is the scoreboard?
What counts a clan match in the league?why dont 1v1s count?
What are the official rules?can i make air lab and combomb?can I dgun a commander?can i laser a commander to death and win?

Seems like a drama thread instead of what it should have been.
If there is not gonna be at least a simple visual scoreboard this will not last long I am 95% sure.

---big question mark---
Yan this thread needs less idiotic posts not more :x

All you asked is answered in the first post, except maybe the very last one. We have been playing kill everything game mode so far, does that need to be made into a rule?
As for official rules, spring.exe is the judge of the winner? Since when has XTA been played with any special rules?

e: also about 1v1s, theres a propper ladder for that, this is for team clan games.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 14 Apr 2010, 22:58
by Tim-the-maniac
Spawn_Retard wrote:im not crying, you all knew who he was.


dont troll bait me ray.
I actually thought it was tribulex at first. Got told it was noruas after the game.

Anyway someone gonna make a new thread?

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 09:46
by Spawn_Retard
Tim-the-maniac wrote:
Spawn_Retard wrote:im not crying, you all knew who he was.


dont troll bait me ray.
I actually thought it was tribulex at first. Got told it was noruas after the game.

Anyway someone gonna make a new thread?
either way, tribulex and noruas are both in cox.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 11:10
by Gota
Tim-the-maniac wrote:
Gota wrote:What league?what games?who?where?when?
Where is the scoreboard?
What counts a clan match in the league?why dont 1v1s count?
What are the official rules?can i make air lab and combomb?can I dgun a commander?can i laser a commander to death and win?

Seems like a drama thread instead of what it should have been.
If there is not gonna be at least a simple visual scoreboard this will not last long I am 95% sure.

---big question mark---
Yan this thread needs less idiotic posts not more :x

All you asked is answered in the first post, except maybe the very last one. We have been playing kill everything game mode so far, does that need to be made into a rule?
As for official rules, spring.exe is the judge of the winner? Since when has XTA been played with any special rules?

e: also about 1v1s, theres a propper ladder for that, this is for team clan games.
Ok so in a 2v2 me and another can rush air quickly and combomb both other players and win?

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 12:32
by Teutooni
Yan - ever the bureaucrat.

Fine, I propose these rules for individual games:
  • Whatever both clans agree on.
In case of disagreement ask other clans in the league, most votes (1 per clan) wins.

Happy now?

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 13:23
by Gota
First of all,fuck you and your flames,this is not about me.
Second of all when someone actually does that youll go awhhh thats not fair,thats lame...you broke my penis wha wha wha.

Guess why BA 1v1 games have RULES that say you cant transport your commander into enemy base within 10 minutes of game start?
Because Competitive BA players learned it the hard way.

Saying fine whatever the 2 clans agree on is fail because they wont remember to decide on rules every game-this has happened many times in 1v1s and team games both in xta and ba.
If you'r gonna be responsible than BE responsible for the tourney and make proper rules and not just half-ass it and dismiss someone when he asks a legitimate question.

A clan match is about winning and you are allowed to do anything within the game's framework so estrablish what isnt allowed once and forall to avoid any chees the XTA community is not interested in.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 14:33
by Tim-the-maniac
Gota wrote:Ok so in a 2v2 me and another can rush air quickly and combomb both other players and win?
You can try..

You are assuming I didnt think about these things. In XTA AA is prevalent early game and transports are slow.
The rule is needed in BA? Yeah well guess what, AA is only built as a direct counter to air and transports are fast. Yes yan BA is different to XTA make a note.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 14:36
by Tim-the-maniac
Spawn_Retard wrote:either way, tribulex and noruas are both in cox.
OK I didnt know that. [CoX]king and what does trib play under?

I asked for this info at the start of the thread, woulda saved alot of wasted time back then ><

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 15:42
by Spawn_Retard
Tim-the-maniac wrote:
Spawn_Retard wrote:either way, tribulex and noruas are both in cox.
OK I didnt know that. [CoX]king and what does trib play under?

I asked for this info at the start of the thread, woulda saved alot of wasted time back then ><
dude, one minute you want who's playing by playing by name, and then you dont give a fuck who plays.


make up your mind.

Ask someone else, im not in the tourney.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 16:17
by pintle
This thread is incredibly lol because you are proposing we play competitive XTA with the current morph/dgun and live dynamic in play. Its just completely retarded.

Any competitive XTA game should be played kill all coms= end, with no retarded special rules for butthurt BA players who dont know how to make AA/counter rush the air starter.

Re: Clan Ladder/League

Posted: 15 Apr 2010, 17:09
by Teutooni
You know, I was going to write a detailed list, 1000m/e start, normal coms, kill all enemy comms, no dgun-and-live etc. But I figured if both clans wanted to do something silly like start with upgraded commanders or whatever, it'd still be a valid clan match.