Page 2 of 12

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 02 Jun 2009, 23:57
by MR.D
nah, Do it as a balance change, for 1 release. what can that hurt?

Just so its a forced part of the game, if it doesn't work out after getting a good run in the regular day to day public games, then release a patch a day later and call it good.

If you don't force an option like that, nobody will manually set it up then noboby will ever know if its good or not.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 02:58
by Anyone
no wreck + not transportable maybe?

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 14:45
by BaNa
this is not ca. ba proper is not for testing ideas. ggnore

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 14:52
by Regret
Let's try including morphing, and jumping units, and and and mex overdrive, just for one version!!1 It is a great idea in my opinion so it must be a great idea!

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 14:52
by Pxtl
Anyone wrote:no wreck + not transportable maybe?
You'd still have commbombing on smaller maps. The comm has feet. Remember when commbombing was the preferred tactic on Altored?

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 14:58
by TheFatController
There's already options to discourage combombing (kill all commanders) and prevent it (com ends).

It might be cool to have an AA2.23 hover commanders type modoption however which would do all of the above and not be overly desirable.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 15:22
by Pxtl
TheFatController wrote:There's already options to discourage combombing (kill all commanders) and prevent it (com ends).

It might be cool to have an AA2.23 hover commanders type modoption however which would do all of the above and not be overly desirable.
Adding CA-style commanders (no dgun, cheap wreck, no commboom) as a modoption would probably be enough, rather than switching to a whole new unit.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 15:28
by Regret
Pxtl wrote:Adding CA-style commanders (no dgun, cheap wreck, no commboom) as a modoption would probably be enough, rather than switching to a whole new unit.
No.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 15:29
by Pxtl
Hey, it was TheFat who was talking about Hovercomms as a modoption - my point was that the CA-style comms would be easier to implement than bringing back the hovercomms.

But either wya, the modoptions list is cluttered-enough as it is.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 16:22
by pintle
I would enjoy a no com corpse modoption, if I ever could ever get a team game with it enabled.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 17:11
by Regret
If you want sissy gameplay for your newbie needs, go play XTA or CA, they offer just the thing.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 17:28
by pintle
This sissy sees some positive aspects in BA gameplay, one of the things that detracts significantly from me enjoying my noobish fumbling about is the terrible slippery slope in team games, when my ally of vastly superior skill to myself dies to some nooby player making lots of units instead of porcing like he should, and this noob then goes on to make *even more* units with the reclaimed metal, generally ending the game very quickly.

I would much prefer my SpeedMetal and DSDrevXXXTREME 8v8s to be no com corpse and kill all coms= game ends.

I appreciate that even having it included as a mod option is incredibly insulting to elite pro's such as Regret, and I am sorry to have even proposed that we clutter up that gui, on that tab that you most likely never look at.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 17:34
by Regret
pintle wrote:This sissy sees some positive aspects in BA gameplay, one of the things that detracts significantly from me enjoying my noobish fumbling about is the terrible slippery slope in team games, when my ally of vastly superior skill to myself dies to some nooby player making lots of units instead of porcing like he should, and this noob then goes on to make *even more* units with the reclaimed metal, generally ending the game very quickly.

I would much prefer my SpeedMetal and DSDrevXXXTREME 8v8s to be no com corpse and kill all coms= game ends.

I appreciate that even having it included as a mod option is incredibly insulting to elite pro's such as Regret, and I am sorry to have even proposed that we clutter up that gui, on that tab that you most likely never look at.
I respect your submission to my superiority.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 18:09
by YokoZar
If you want to stop comm bombing just make the commanders invincible :idea:

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 18:14
by pintle
All coms end/no wreck encourages tactical combombing, in the sense that it is a powerful move, but reduces your team's "lives".

I don't have any problem whatsoever with com drop/bombing, I've just seen too many team games go to shit when 1 player throws away his com, and an average or above player gets hold of the wreck.

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 18:17
by tombom
YokoZar wrote:If you want to stop comm bombing just make the commanders invincible :idea:
if this change was made i kind of wonder if any of the people who play 8v8 would actually change their "tactics" at all

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 20:10
by Anyone
Remove the commanders!
Ok Regret would then actually have to learn how to play BA, but apart from that....

*ducks* :mrgreen:

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 20:55
by flop
bantha mega self d was fun, put it back

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 21:01
by 1v0ry_k1ng
BAAAAAAWWW CHANGE
/pro ba player post

Re: Balanced Annihilation V6.95

Posted: 03 Jun 2009, 21:14
by Pxtl
flop wrote:bantha mega self d was fun, put it back
What, it's gone? When did that happen??